Title: Short-range charge order reveals the role of disorder in the pseudogap state of high-Tc superconductors

Abstract: The main obstacle towards explaining superconductivity in copper-oxides resides in the mysterious nature of their pseudogap state. Most controversial is whether a genuine (static and long-ranged) ordered phase universally lies behind the diverse indications of symmetry breaking in this state. Here, using nuclear magnetic resonance in YBa2Cu3Oy, we identify a phenomenology that unifies existing results: while no static magnetic order is detected, charge order in the pseudogap state is static, though only short-ranged, it is accompanied by probable intra-unit-cell nematic order and its impacts on most transport and spectroscopic properties. However, we find that this universal phenomenology is insufficient to conclude on the intrinsic nature of the pseudogap state. Indeed, because charge order is found to be pinned by native defects even in such a clean cuprate, it is unknown whether it would be static and long-ranged or fluctuating and short-ranged in the absence of disorder. Recognising the impact of disorder thus appears to be key to elucidating whether any electronic order in the pseudogap state is intrinsically static or fluctuating.