Title: General and specific utility measures for synthetic data

Abstract: Data holders can produce synthetic versions of data sets when concerns about potential disclosure restrict the availability of the original records. This paper is concerned with methods to judge whether such synthetic data have a distribution that is comparable to that of the original data, what we call general utility. We consider how general utility compares with specific utility, i.e., the analytical similarity of the synthetic data to the original data. If general and specific utility are comparable, data holders can use the former to evaluate potential synthetic data releases in place of the latter. We adapt a previous general measure of data utility, the propensity score mean-squared-error (pMSE), to the specific case of synthetic data and derive its distribution for the case when the correct synthesis model is used to create the synthetic data. Our asymptotic results are confirmed by a simulation study. We also consider two specific utility measures, confidence interval overlap and standardized difference in summary statistics, which we compare with the general utility results. We present two examples examining this comparison of general and specific utility to real data syntheses and make recommendations for their use by data holders.