Title: Students emergent understanding of statistical modeling through parametric inference

Abstract: Statistical thinking partially depends upon an iterative process by which one identifies and maps essential features of a problem setting onto an abstract model or archetype, and then translates this abstract structure back into the context of the original problem setting (Wild & Pfannkuch, 1999). Assessment in introductory statistics often relies on tasks that present students with data in context and expects them to choose and describe an appropriate model. This study explores an alternative task that explicitly presents students with an elementary paradigm for statistical inference, and then prompts students to clearly identify a sample, population, statistic, and parameter using a context of their own invention. The study data include free-text narrative responses of a random sample of 500 students from a national sample of more than 1600 introductory statistics students from the United States. Student responses were scrutinized and categorized in order to explore emergent understanding and communication of foundational concepts related to statistical inference and modeling. Results suggest that responses often portrayed sample and population accurately. Portrayals of statistic and parameter were significantly less reliable, and were associated with descriptions of a wide variety of other concepts. Responses frequently attributed a variable of some kind to the statistic, or a study design detail to the parameter. Implications for instruction related to foundational concepts such as parameter and the necessity for emphasis on a modeling paradigm in introductory statistics are discussed.