Title: A dynamical approach to Zipf's law

Abstract: The rank-size plots of very different systems are usually described in terms of Zipf's law, but the deep meaning of this scaling law is still controversial. We show how usual criteria used to identify Zipf's scaling fail to capture an essential feature of this phenomenon, that is the coherent evolution of the system and the space in which it is embedded. We therefore identify a Zipfian dynamics in terms of dynamical constraints which relate in time the level of sampling and the parameters of the probability distribution of sizes. This permits to introduce the concepts of coherent evolution, which is the key ingredient to develop a genuine Zipf's behaviour. We finally discuss a number of practical examples. For instance, earthquakes can evolve only incoherently and thus show only a spurious Zipf's law, while natural language dynamics is intrinsically Zipfian due to dynamical coherence imposed by grammar rules.