Title: Topological Order in the Six-Vertex Antiferromagnet and its Breakdown in Spin Ice

Abstract: We present a loop-representation to compare two similar anti-ferromagnets: the Rys F-model and the realistic square ice. In the F-model, we argue, below the N\'eel temperature loops are topologically trivial and the system undergoes the usual $ \mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetry breaking for the staggered order parameter. Above transition, loops become non-trivial while a symmetry breaking chooses loop parity. Further, magnetization is an homotopy invariant of the loops, leading to zero susceptibility below a critical field. In spin ices, instead, monopoles erase this rich topological structure.