Title: Critical topological Anderson insulator

Abstract: Two-dimensional topological insulators (TI) feature robust metallic edges with quantized conductance protected by an insulating bulk gap. Strong disorder, however, eventually drives the system to the trivial Anderson insulator (AI), suppressing edge conductance. We study the nature of this transition and establish it as happening through a distinct phase called the critical topological insulator (CTI). Scaling behavior with increasing system size can distinguish these three phases with the longitudinal conductance of the TI/CTI phase converging exponentially/polynomially to the quantized value, while the conductance manifest in the exponential AI phase showing no size dependence. We claim analytically this observation using the self-consistent Born approximation. In particular, we associate the boundary between these phases with the imaginary part of the effective self-energy, introducing an analytical tool to predict various aspects of the disorder-topology interplay. We use our analytical theory, supported by direct numerical simulations, to study the effect of disorder range on the topological Anderson insulator. Interestingly, while this phase is quite generic for uncorrelated or short-range disorder, it is strongly suppressed by long-range disorder, perhaps explaining why it has never been seen in solid state systems.