Title: Metastable states in the $J_1-J_2$ Ising model

Abstract: Competing interactions of nearest and next-nearest-neighbor electron spins on a lattice with coupling constants ${J_1}$ and ${J_2}$, respectively, give the system some interesting and unusual properties and may even underlie high temperature superconductivity according to the resonating valence bond theory. Here we study the ${ J_1-J_2}$ Ising model on the square lattice using the Random local field approximation (RLFA) and Monte Carlo (MC) simulations for various values of the ratio ${p = J_2/|J_1|}$. We show that the accuracy of RLFA is comparable to the mean field cluster approximation, but, in addition, and most surprisingly, RLFA predicts metastable states with zero polarization at low temperature for ${p \in (0,1)}$. This is confirmed by our MC simulations, in which the system reaches these states after the energy relaxation of initially randomly oriented spins. Furthermore, in a moderate external field, the MC simulations reveal the existence of still other metastable states with nonzero polarizations. These states also appear when the initial state before relaxation has a nonzero polarization. We list compounds appropriate for experimental verification of our predictions, with high-temperature superconductors being the most suitable. These findings could be crucial for explaining the magnetic and electric properties of materials, in particular, under ultrafast nonequilibrium conditions.