Title: Intrinsic planar Hall effect in magnetic Weyl semimetals

Abstract: The magneto-transport measurements for Weyl semimetals (WSMs) show that the planar Hall effect (PHE) can be viewed as the topological response of WSMs. It is believed that the PHE in WSMs only appears as an extrinsic effect. Indeed, there is no reported intrinsic PHE (IPHE) in WSMs either theoretically or experimentally. Herein, guided by symmetry, we predict the IPHE in magnetic WSMs with the second-order semiclassical theory. We find that the IPHE conductivity tensor features an antisymmetric form, in sharp contrast with the extrinsic one predicted in [\textcolor{blue}{Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 176804 (2017)}]. We reveal that tilting the Weyl cone in the out-of-plane direction is the key to observing this effect. Moreover, when the tilt direction is fixed, by tuning the angle formed by $\vec{E}$ and $\vec{B}$ to switch off the \textit{chiral anomaly}, we find that the IPHE responses driven by Berry curvature still exist, indicating the fundamental role of Berry curvature as the origin of IPHE in WSMs than the \textit{chiral anomaly}. Finally, the experimental strategy to detect the IPHE is discussed.