Title: An Empirical Study on Release Engineering of Artificial Intelligence Products

Abstract: Due to the popularity of artificial intelligence (AI), more and more AI software products are developed. Because of the lack of specialized AI knowledge, domain data and computational resource, developers are in great need of transfer learning-based AI product development. Such need is satisfied by model zoos and stores, where pretrained deep learning (DL) assets are shared. By integrating the DL assets, developers can give their product AI ability. But the activity behind this simple sentence can be non-trivial. Like traditional software products, AI products will also go through release engineering (RE) process, which is part of software development and includes steps like integration, testing, system building and deployment. Considering RE for transfer learning based AI product development is very helpful to make the products better. But the differences between AI products and traditional software products make the concerns and required efforts hard to be figured out and estimated. Unfortunately, currently few research focus has been put on RE for AI products. This research tries to fill the gap. First, we do the investigation. We look into the deployment scenarios supported by TensorFlow and PyTorch, the top 2 widely used DL frameworks. We also look into 2 model zoos, TFHub (AIHub TensorFlow module) and PyTorch Hub where DL assets developed by TensorFlow and PyTorch are shared. The family phenomenon and version issue on model zoos are investigated. Second, we figured out the concerns and efforts during the RE for AI products. We propose a best practice for the development of transfer learning-based AI products and a case study is conducted to verify the feasibility of the proposed practice. This research can be helpful for AI product developers in their development activities.